Your Song
Tiny Dancer
Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word
I Guess That's Why They Call It The Blues
Rocket Man
Per il concerto speciale in occasione del 125° anniversario della Yamaha da tenere al Disneyland’s Hyperion Theater, ad Anaheim, California
c'erano delle ottime premesse: trasmissione in diretta via web,
orchestra di 60 elementi condotta da James Newton Howard e supervisione
musicale di Nathan East. Si poteva sperare in qualche
grandiosa riproposta di brani storici sfruttando questa grande
orchestra, ma purtroppo tutte le speranze sono naufragate di fronte a
una misera scaletta di cinque canzoni, di cui sole tra accompagnate
dall'orchestra con le solite hit e la presenza sempre pił inspiegabile
di I Guess ... L'ennesima grande occasione sprecata.
© 2013 Paul Purcell
Where's The Orchestra? Billy Joel once sang...
Elton
helped celebrate Yamaha's 125th anniversary by doing an all too
infrequent style of show. With the wonderful James Newton Howard at the
baton, Elton's concert conductor of choice, we were to be treated to
five songs from the greatest songbook of this or any other era. The
first two songs, Your Song and Tiny Dancer featured the original Paul
Buckmaster arrangemets tastefully and measuredly spruced up by James. As
James said himself in the past, the arrangements were intricate parts
of the original songs, not after thoughts. So it's with great
disappopintment that the sound mix was so poor that we never got to hear
them fully realised. Especially when they pulled a master stroke and
removed the rhythm section and guitar parts and left a wonderful tight
link between the the piano and orchestra in the form of up right bass
played by Nathan East, for many years the bass player of Eric Clapton.
By doing this, we could (or would have!) hear the great brass
announcement that James added on the final verse of Tiny Dancer or the
dramatic entrance of the low end of the strings on the first chorus.
Sorry Seems To Be featured James' own score, again with embellishments
of the original. The woodwinds on the chorus perfectly responding to
Elton's vocal. Then as it was a Yamaha event, it was time to showcase
the said piano. For which Elton picked two songs that would give both
sides of his Nice And Slow repertoire. I Guess That's Why slid along as
smooth as the soulful vocal Elton always finds for it. Where earlier
Elton and sixty people had held sway, he was now center stage. But the
sound had not lessened, nor the intensity of the moment. Then Rocket Man
introduced us a new intro in the new year...a stop start vocal with the
piano notes left to hang from the rafters of the auditorium. The piano
man was making his stand...needless to say his vocal soared to the same
lofty heights. Which at the moment is in its best shape for years.
Dexterous with a depth and a flexiblity that can wrap itself around the
great lyrics. Some final remarks. This is the sort of show Elton should
do more of. The sound of Elton and the orchestra without the band caught
the moment right. Both parties could exist in their seperate worlds
while at the same time work in perfect harmony. We don't hear those
arrangemets organically enough, the surge as the space Elton created in
his music is filled with a perfectly fitted layer. James Newton Howard
knows Elton's music like the baton he holds. Having played all the early
arrangemets on the keyboards in the 70's and 80's live not to mention
the orchestra tours in days of yore, he can pre-empt any move Elton can
make. Possibly even those he hasn't made yet! This show should be toured
in this from without delay. I believe that now that from now on every
Yamaha showroom from Azerbaijan to Zimbabwe will now play a recording of
that portion of the show to sell their product...hopefully with the
sound corrected!
|
© 2013 Brian Gold
The good and the bad...
Looking appropriately sparkly, and perfectly dressed for the occasion,
Elton took the stage and wowed both the audience and the internet
audience. The 60 piece orchestra, lead by James Newton Howard was a
perfect accompaniment to Elton's solo performance on the Yamaha
Disklavier. Elton was in fine voice, once described by a reporter as "A voice from Mount Olympus." I couldn't agree more. Now for the criticisms...
I realize that Yamaha wanted to feature their instrument, but when you
have a 60 piece orchestra backing you, for god's sake, turn down the
string sound on the Disklavier! It constantly overpowered the actual
string section in the orchestra. I don't know if there was also a bass
sound coming out of the Disklavier, but it seemed that way. It was also
overpowering at times. The piano sound alone would have been more than
enough to show off Elton's playing, the Disklavier, and to make full use
of the amazing orchestra. That leads us into the second issue that I
had with the concert: If you're going to play only 5 songs, USE THE
ORCHESTRA ON ALL FIVE! What a tremendous waste to have an orchestra
behind you and use it on only 3 songs! I imagine that this was Yamaha's
decision to feature the Disklavier, but in that case, why have the
orchestra at all? This was a really poor decision. Elton sounds
incredible solo on the piano. We can all agree on that. But this concert
was billed as a concert with an orchestra, so why let the orchestra
just sit there?! It's extremely rare to hear Elton make a mistake on
the piano, but to make at least 4 (that I remember) during Rocket Man
alone? Unheard of! It's not that he was off his game in general, but he
did hit more than a couple of wrong notes. Very unusual for a pianist of
Elton's caliber. Again there was that problem with the piano/string
sound that was coming out of the Disklavier. When Elton was hitting the
high notes on the piano, the string sound became unbearable. It was
actually annoying and taking away from the performance. I know that the
volume on the string sound can be altered in real time. Didn't anybody
realize what was happening? Having said all that, and having been
fairly harsh in doing so, let me end by saying that it is always a joy
for me to hear Elton play live. He is truly THE artist of not just my
generation but those that came before me, and those that followed. I
hope that next time he's backed by an orchestra, he'll make full use of
it as he has done in the past. Respectfully submitted, Brian Gold
|
cliccare sulle immagini per ingrandire
|